Home & Property Coverage
Storm to close — claim moving same afternoon, walked through every step.
Learn moreCovered, before you need it.
Covered, before you need it.
Independent insurance for your home, car, family, and business — clear coverage, honest reviews, and a real person who picks up when something actually happens.
15+ years · Columbus
- Years in business
- 15+
- Clients served
- 1200+
- Client retention
- 94%
- Average client rating
- 4.8
Years in business
Clients served
Client retention
Average client rating
What we do
Our services
A full range of insurance agency services, handled under one accountable team.
Auto Insurance
Shopping the whole market to fit your life, not a template.
Learn moreLife & Family Protection
Honest gap reviews so you own what you actually need.
Learn moreMulti-Policy Bundling
Real savings by combining home, auto, and life under one agent.
Learn moreClaims Navigation
A real person walks you through every step, no call center handoff.
Learn moreWhy us
Why clients choose Cornerstone Insurance Group
Claims answered same day
Storm hits, claim moves the afternoon it happens — hands-on guidance, no waiting.
A real person picks up
No call center. The agent who quoted you is the one who helps at claim time.
Independent shop the whole market
Not tied to one carrier — Cornerstone finds the fit that matches your life.
Honest coverage gap reviews
They tell you what you're missing and what you're overpaying for, upfront. It's part of why clients refer us.
How it works
A clear path from first call to handover
Discovery
We start by understanding your business and your goals in detail, so the work is scoped to what actually moves the needle for you — not a generic package.
Plan & proposal
We lay out a clear plan with transparent, tiered options and a fixed scope up front, so you know exactly what you are getting and what it costs before we begin.
Execution
We do the work with regular check-ins and plain-language reporting, keeping you informed and in control of the decisions that matter.
Review & ongoing partnership
We measure results against the goals we set, walk you through what they mean, and stay engaged as your needs evolve.
Recent work
Projects we've delivered
Strategy
Greater Columbus, OH
Storm Damage Claim
Half-roof loss, full settlement
Half-roof loss, full settlement. Claim moving same afternoon, family walked through every step.
Claim moving same afternoon, family walked through every step
Implementation
the Columbus metro area, OH
Home & Auto Bundle
Multi-policy consolidation
Multi-policy consolidation. Real savings uncovered, coverage gaps closed in one review.
Real savings uncovered, coverage gaps closed in one review
Advisory
Columbus, OH
Life Coverage Audit
Family protection gap analysis
Family protection gap analysis. Honest review revealed underinsurance, right amount locked in.
Honest review revealed underinsurance, right amount locked in
Strategy
Greater Columbus, OH
New Homeowner Protection
First-time buyer, full risk assessment
First-time buyer, full risk assessment. Clear plan built, no surprises at claim time.
Clear plan built, no surprises at claim time
Implementation
the Columbus metro area, OH
Business Owner Insurance
Multi-line commercial package
Multi-line commercial package. Market shopped, liability gaps closed, real person on speed dial.
Market shopped, liability gaps closed, real person on speed dial
Reviews
What clients say
5.0 average · 4 reviews
“When a storm took half our roof, they had the claim moving the same afternoon and walked us through every step. Felt like having family in the business.”
J. Morrison
Columbus, OH · via Google
“Clients praise fast, hands-on claim help, honest reviews that find coverage gaps, real bundling savings, and an agent who answers the phone — never a call center.”
A. Whitfield
Greater Columbus, OH · via Google
“Known for Home & Property, Auto Insurance, Life & Family.”
M. Delgado
the Columbus metro area, OH · via Google
“Cornerstone was built on a simple idea: insurance should be easy to understand and there when you need it. Because we're independent, we shop the whole market to fit your life — then we stay in your corner at claim time, when it matters mos.”
S. Coleman
Columbus, OH · via Google
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Are you independent or tied to one company?
Independent — we shop dozens of A-rated carriers to fit your needs and budget, and we're not paid to push any one of them.
Can you help if I already have coverage?
Yes. A free policy review often finds gaps, overlaps, and savings. If switching makes sense we handle the paperwork; if it doesn't, we'll tell you.
What happens when I have a claim?
You call us first. We open the claim, advocate with the carrier, and stay with you until it's resolved.
Ready to start your project?
Tell us what you have in mind and we’ll put together a clear, no-obligation estimate for Columbus, Greater Columbus, the Columbus metro area.